She Said It Probably Didn't Exist. We Found It Anyway.

A couple of years ago, I met a client named Callann. Like a lot of my clients, she came to me with more than a checklist of square footage and bedrooms. She came with a dream.

Callann wanted a farm

Not just land, but a real working property with a house where she could host events, gather people, and build something rooted in one place. But there was a catch. She wasn't ready to give up her life in New York City. She kept an apartment there, and whatever property she found needed to be close enough that a trip from Manhattan wouldn't feel like a journey. Close enough that her friends would actually show up.


When she first described it to me, she was honest. She didn't think it existed. A working farm with room to host, within reach of the city, on a piece of land that felt like an escape without being out of reach. It's the kind of wish list that sounds more like a fantasy than a real estate search.


We got to work anyway.


Months of searching later, we found it. In Pawling, New York. A property that checked every box on a list most people would have called impossible. Close enough to the city. Big enough for the farm she pictured. Right for the events she wanted to host. The kind of place she could actually build a life around, without giving up the one she already had.


This is the part of the job that doesn't show up in a listing photo. It's not just matching buyers to houses. It's listening long enough to understand what someone is really asking for, and not giving up when the search takes longer than expected.

If you've got a property in your head that feels impossible to find, let's talk about it. Sometimes it's closer than you think.


By Jessica Watts • October 26, 2026
When you love a piece of land, you start to think about what happens to it long after it’s yours. The rolling meadow you walk every morning. The stand of old trees at the edge of the property. The stream that floods a little every spring. Those places don’t have to change hands and disappear. What happens to your land
By Jessica Watts • October 19, 2026
As we get deeper into fall, it seems our economic and interest rate picture is changing rapidly.
By Jessica Watts • October 12, 2026
You can scroll through every listing in Katonah from your couch tonight. You can see the square footage, the acreage, the stone walls, and the kitchen renovation from 2019.
More Posts